I am told I cannot pick my home appraiser. Is this true?

December 21, 2015

The rules have changed and it is highly likely you cannot utilize your appraiser of choice when applying for a mortgage loan.

Appraisal - Pixabay

Reader Question: A lender is telling me I cannot pick my home appraiser I know to be a solid appraiser, and that the lending rules have changed. We have not purchased a home for fifteen years. Is this true? And if it is true, why did the rules change? Jerry G.

Monty’s Answer: The simple answer is the rules have changed. If you are relying on a lender that sells the mortgage to a Government Sponsored Enterprises(GSE) under the supervision of the Federal Housing Finance Agency(FHFA) or the Federal Housing Administration (FHA), you will be unable to pick your appraiser. GSE’s account for a large percentage of home mortgages originated today.  

Some background

Many savvy practitioners and observers of real estate lending and the federal government’s legislative actions attribute the run-up in real estate prices and the subsequent real estate meltdown in large part to two contributing factors in the years before 2008:

  1. Derivatives of Mortgage-Backed Securities – For example, America’s most well-known “practitioner,” Warren Buffet, in the 2008 Berkshire Hathaway Annual Report stated “The stupefying losses in mortgage-related securities came in large part because of flawed, history-based models used by salesmen, rating agencies and investors.” Many taxpayers do not realize they paid about half-a-trillion dollars of the “stupefying losses”.
  2. Washington DC’s desire to increase the percentage of American homeowners – This was accomplished by encouraging lending institutions to find ways to make home ownership available to more consumers. The lenders accommodated the politicians by relaxing lending requirements, such as appraisal criteria, and creating new rules, such as “stated income” mortgages, where the borrower was not obligated to furnish evidence of their earnings.   

The combination of these elements was an elixir for disaster. Relaxed lending policies and “stated income” high-risk mortgages packaged as derivatives and sold to investors was folly. When home values collapsed with the stock market and homeowners realized their mortgages were much larger than the market value of the property, many walked away.    

The aftermath

In 2010, the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act was enacted to prevent the meltdown of 2008 from repeating itself in the future. This legislation added many new administrative rules for lenders to follow. All six steps in the process of mortgage loan origination have been affected. One of the steps most impacted is the appraisal phase.  

The new mortgage loan procedures

Pre-qualification for a mortgage loan is the new first step. Many lenders treat a pre-qualification similar to a pre-approval. Before a home has been identified, the borrower is partially underwritten and pre-approved. Once the borrower knows the dollar amount the lender will supply they shop and contract for their new home, subject to the lender determining their collateral is solid, hence the appraisal, among other underwriting requirements.

Ordering the appraisal

A new service called an Appraisal Management Company (AMC) has risen out of Dodd -Frank. This service is utilized to order the appraisal. Instead of calling an appraiser, the lender calls an AMC. The AMC ensures there is no collusion or pressure applied between the lender, or the borrower, with the appraiser. The AMC also identifies qualified appraisers, obtains fee quotes and ensures a random rotation of appraisers is available to serve the lender’s customers. They act as the information conduit between the lender/borrower and the appraiser. AMC’s are not an optional service.

Adapting to change

When AMC’s came into existence, some appraisers ceased making appraisals for mortgage loans. There were a variety of reasons; lost relationships, government intervention, a squeeze on fee income, more procedures, additional appraisal requirements, and more. Some lender staff also saw the change as a signal to retire or take on a new line of work. Other players stayed and adapted and new players have stepped in as the market has improved. This new learning curve was taking place in a difficult housing environment with confusion and uncertainty in every sector of the industry. Both large national AMC firms and more regional firms populate the marketplace today.  

New technology
The new TILA-RESPA Integrated Disclosure (TRID) changed the rules and modified software programs forms like “Auto Underwriter.” The goal is to help lenders improve the loan process for consumers. Some lenders, like Brannon Bartley, of Citywide Home Loans in Scottsdale, AZ, sees some, but not all, of the new rules as helpful. Other lenders, who wished to remain anonymous for this article, believe the new rules are an expensive new bureaucracy that adds cost to the consumer.